“Exploring Reality in Virtual Worlds” with Piet Hut

Tue, Jan 15, 2008


Astrophysicist Piet Hut (Pema Pera in Second Life) has come into virtual worlds to explore questions about reality. Piet’s interest in reality is the question of what reality really is. His exploration starts with scientific insights and moves into the reaches of contemplative traditions and other ways of knowing to ask: “What else is true?”

Simulating stars and galaxies and putting them in the palm of your hand computationally speaking is interestingly complementary to much of the ancient imagery of India, Tibet, etc.

Tibetans/Indians used “waking up” as a metaphor for seeing more directly into reality, but we now have many more examples we can use, besides waking up from a dream: realizing that a movie is a movie, getting out of and into virtual realities, so many metaphors that all can serve to help us talk about radically different ways of seeing in a new light what what is already right here.

Piets experiments in virtual worlds began with Videoranch (founded by Michael Nesmith, one of the original Monkees, and his wife), and now Qwaq Forums and Second Life. Piet is planning to write a book with the tentative title “Exploring Reality in Virtual Worlds.” He is a professor at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, but is currently logging in from Kyoto Japan where he is involved in joint research with Japanese astrophysicists.

In the picture opening this post, by Noelani Lightfoot the proprietor of Quixotic Photography in Second Life (see more of her great work here), Piet and I are at a Go table in Second Life (see the newsblog and  the website for a schedule of events). Piet is a Go player (shodan rank in Japan) and at the time of the interview he had just discovered this place, to his delight.

Piet explained to me how the trajectory of his research into the notion of “the lab” and his journey as an astrophysicist in virtual worlds relates to the history of astrophysics:

Science goes back to astronomy, studying the regularity of the heavens, and moderns science started with Galileo. Yet, though astrophysics is the oldest science, it is the youngest laboratory science. Until half a century ago it had no lab, while all other sciences did. You couldn’t put a star in a lab, or a galaxy. But with the advent of computers, you can, virtually! So experimental astrophysics equals virtual worlds, in fact a virtual cosmos.

Piet takes the notion of “the lab” into new terrain.


Piet began with two experiments in Qwaq. The first is a Qwaq forum called MICA (Meta-Institute for Computational Astrophysics). Aimed at his astrophysics colleagues, MICA explores what happens when astrophysicists enter their virtual labs themselves, in virtual form as avatars. The second Qwaq organization, WoK (Ways of Knowing), is aimed at a widely interdisciplinary group of scholars interested in thinking deeply about reality and asking the question, “what do you find if you really delve into contemplation, doing it and reflecting on it, both, i.e. using your life as a lab.”

In astro I am putting galaxies and stars in a lab and in WoK we are treating our own life as a lab and virtual words are great labs!

Piet’s recent article, “Virtual Laboratories and Virtual Worlds,” reports on his experiences with these Qwaq forums and offers many fascinating and intriguing insights. Piet was initially surprised at which group made the transition first, as he put it from tourists to neighbors and then to collaborators. Apparently the task of getting astrophysicists into virtual worlds was a lot like herding cats. An interesting point Piet makes is how:

The main attraction for coming into Qwaq Forums was presence. Presence in a persistent space, a watering hole that quickly became a familiar meeting ground, this is what was felt to be the single most important aspect of the whole enterprise. Everything else was clearly secondary.”

But this week, as Piet explained:

We will start putting our N-body simulations in Qwaq and we will also start playing with interfaces to their in-world applications. Now from here on, Qwaq will prove to be useful for integrating simulations and avatars, i.e. no more screen dividing scientists and their science.

This may be a considerable draw for astrophysicists who will now be able to enter virtual laboratories running real time simulations, produced by a supercomputer, of galaxies “or molecules interacting for that matter” to inspect the results of the simulation, and “even change the way the simulation are run in real time” together with their colleagues in a shared virtual space.

Another potential of virtual worlds that Piet is interested in exploring is “for researchers who are geographically remote to start writing code together in a virtual space.”

The biggest problem in computational science, which is quickly becoming all of science, is to find ways to let scientists write software together.

He notes in “Virtual Laboratories and Virtual Worlds,” that keeping full digital records of coding sessions can be part of a process in which we move “from open source to open knowledge.”

The idea is that if someone uses a legacy code, twenty years from now, and wants to modify a particular function, she can click on a pointer next to the old lines of code and see a replay of the session that produced that code. This will give full disclosure of the original motivation for writing the code, the way in which is was debugged, what considerations came up and were tried out, anything you could possibly have wanted to ask the original writers (except that they by then will have forgotten most of it!).

Breaking out of walled gardens (intellectual disciplines and proprietary virtual worlds)


Piet’s commitment to exploring different ways of knowing extends now beyond breaking down the boundaries between science and contemplative traditions. He is also forming groups that bridge virtual worlds. Piet has invited me to join two groups: one is the Qwaq Second Life Liason group, QSL, (more about this later in this post), and the other The WoK Qwaq forum .

I will have some first hand accounts of my own experiences bridging worlds soon. My first WoK forum featured a presentation by Dr. Karen Sobel Lojeski, founder of Virtual Distance International, and a discussion of the New York Times article on virtual worlds for children – what the implications of the widespread adoption of virtual worlds by children may be for mind and society, and whether these burgeoning children’s worlds were benefiting children or merely opportunist business ventures.

Karen’s book with Dr. Richard Reilly, “Uniting the Virtual Workforce: Transforming Leadership and Innovation in the Globally Integrated Enterprise,” is scheduled for publication in April, 2008, and you can order now on,, or

I am interested in the endeavor of working across the disciplines of science and contemplative traditions. But I wonder how the emphasis of many contemplative traditions to go beyond conceptual reality meshes with science.

For example, in Buddhism there is a distinction between certainty about the nature of reality and the experience of what reality really is – which is beyond conceptual fabrication. To go beyond conceptual fabrication is to go beyond the language of science, indeed beyond any language. If science made its endeavor the experience of the true nature of reality beyond concept would it still be science? Piet told me that while current science cannot play such a role, he fully expects a future science to be able to do so (see his one-page summary, Beyond Methods and Goals).

I am equally interested to see how Second Lifer’s and Qwaqers will find new ways to relate. As Piet put it:

Let’s build bridges. The human part is always the most difficult, so why not start there scaling the walls. And Qwaq and SL communities have a lot to offer each other. They are totally complementary.

Exploring Qwaq

Here are some pictures of my first day in Qwaq. I had a bit of culture shock when I checked in and found myself not the rather lovely Tara5 Oh, my Second Life avatar, but a block person. Luckily being able to drag Powerpoint presentations from my desktop onto a wall in a virtual room in one second with one mouse motion saved the day, so I was a happy blockhead.


Then I learned how to become a sphere (see picture below) which for me actually felt a whole lot better. There is no rich culture to support avatar identity construction in Qwaq, as there is in Second Life, and without this I preferred to retreat into a non figurative abstraction.

In Qwaq people frequently use a real life still image of their face to give more of an identity to their blockheads. Piet explained how they had experimented with using streaming video. But, he noted, the effect was a bit disappointing because the disjuncture between the moving image, which had no connection to what the avatar was actually saying or doing, was worse than when a still picture was used. Yet the richness of facial expression added to the communication, so the jury is still out, he said, as to what might work best: “time and further testing and tinkering will tell.”

Piet came into Qwaq and showed me this nice mirror in the space of Dr. Robert Magrisso, Doctor of Internal Medicine, an avid Qwaqer. In the picture below the mirror with images of our qwaq avatars in it has Dr Magrisso’s paintings to the right and left. There is a reflection of my happy blue sphere. And, Piet and his alt are the orange spheres (you can run multiple Qwaq sessions on the same computer, making it easy to log in with two avatars, or to be present in two Qwaq organizations simultaneously).

The mirror is very nice and I have not seen one in Second Life. Apparently there are a few according to my friend Zha Ewry. But they are not easy to make because of rendering issues, “You need a primitive that ‘acts like a mirror’ in the graphics system.” Apparently there has been some discussion about adding “mirror” to prim surfaces in Second Life but it’s graphically expensive and would use too much rendering resources as it would need to be calculated every frame. But Zha notes, “They are pretty. And, there are some tricks you can do on higher end graphics cards to make them less costly for clients.”


Second Life the great virtual lab of fairy tale, dream, technology, community and more….

In the last few weeks Piet has expanded his explorations of reality in virtual worlds into Second Life. Though as Pema Pera he was born ten months ago, he was so busy with Qwaq that he had to wait for the Xmas holidays to get acculturated into SL, which has a learning curve steeper than for Qwaq by two orders of magnitude, he said. But now that he’s in, he shows all the signs of being hooked.

Second Life as the largest and most popular virtual world, whose rich social structure of networks built around user generated content, is the supreme realm or “lab” to explore, “fairy tale, dream, technology, community, etc., etc, …” and the infinite possibilities of networked human intelligence.

Piet has started a Qwaq Second Life Liason group with Kat Lemieux, a Director and Founder of The International Space Museum in Second Life. “Kat has been a wonderful mentor for me here in SL,” Piet told me. Henrik Bennetsen (formerly Henrik Linden), from Stanford, was instrumental in getting Piet involved with Second Life. Piet explained, “I met Henrik in RL at a conference in Stanford about using virtual worlds as collaboration tools in August. Henrik pointed me to Kat and the rest is history.”

Because Kat’s last name is in French, I came up with the name liaison, Qwaq-SL Liaision. Then, with an incredible stroke of good luck, it turned out that QSL, the abbreviation of the group , had a deep meaning in early radio broadcasting, which I did not even know.

So then QSL grew very fast. Emileigh Starbrook showed her simulation of an asteroid impact on Mars, an amazing performance. And I got astronaut Ed Lu in at the space station. Kat showed some Qwaqers how to build things in SL. And I got Troy Mcluhan and Kat into Qwaq, in my MICA organization, and now you too, in my WoK organization.

Adventures with The Qwaq Second Life Liason Group


The Qwaq Second Life Liason Group, QSL, has grown rapidly and is now holding three meetings a week, each next one roughly six hours later than the previous one, since members span Europe, Asia and North America. I joined them on Wednesday, January 9th for a tour of a replica of Chernobyl in Second Life given by Maxwolf Goodliffe. This Second Life build is part of an effort to raise money for Chernobyl charities. For more about this effort see this YouTube video.

Zazen Manbi, who introduced me to Piet, was there for the tour in his yellow protective suit. Piet is in an earlier incarnation of his avatar here – the bearded avatar in a maroon shirt (just before he learned how to shed his noobe image ;>). Zazen, who is Jeffrey Corbin in RL, recently obtained funding for teaching an environmental impact course in Second Life. Zazen is building a virtual Nuclear Power Station in Second Life to help explain and demystify nuclear power and its vital role in controlling global warming.


A couple of days earlier, Piet brought his friend, astronaut Ed Lu, into Second Life to visit the replica of the International Space Station that he lived in for a half a year in 2003. Ed Lu and Piet were joined by a number of members of the Qwaq Second Life Liason group. The picture above is from Troy McLuhan’s Snapzilla. Ed Lu is the avatar in the white shirt. For more on Ed Lu’s visit to Second Life see Kat Lemieux’s post on the International Space Museum blog.

Piet and Ed Lu, together with Rusty Schweickart and Clark Chapman, founded The B612 Foundation named after the asteroid that was the home of Le Petit Prince. The goal of B612 is to significantly alter the orbit in a controlled manner by 2015. After the tour of Chernobyl in Second Life, Piet and I talked for a while on the solar panels of the SL International Space Station.

Piet described to me how Ed Lu came into Second Life.

He had called me on my cell phone from the space station, when he lived there for half a year in 2003 and two days ago I called him on his cell phone from the SL space station. He was so intrigued, he was willing to come over the next day. We had quite a party! After ten minutes in SL he could talk, walk, fly, and have a text based conversation with his admirers while inspecting the space station. These astronauts are really incredible!

Ed Lu’s visit gave a very auspicious start to the year for QSL which has taken off at rocket speed – good to have some guidance from an RL astronaut! I am very excited to be part of it. Piet has launched some ground breaking communities in virtual worlds in the last year. I can’t wait to see what happens as they develop and expand in 2008.

I think QSL will be visiting the, “The Rhodospin Membrane Protein,” soon. This build on the IBM Research Shared Work Island resulted from a simulation done on the Blue Gene supercomputer. In the picture below, Zha Ewry, Pema Pera and I are sitting in the molecule discussing the meta implications of a visualization of a visual molecule in a virtual world (for more on this build see this post on eightbar, SLNN, and the molecule tour on Destroy TV’s Flickr photostream).


categories: digital public space, Metarati, Metaverse, Mixed Reality, open source, privacy and online identity, privacy in virtual worlds, Second Life, social media, Virtual Citizenship, Virtual Worlds, Web 2.0, Web 3D, Web3.D, World 2.0

3 Comments For This Post

  1. Bernardo Alonso Says:

    Another great post. Keep on coming…. thanks for the Piet Hut article link.

  2. Peter Miller Says:

    There is actually quite a lot of molecule rezzing going on in SL, albeit on a smaller scale than rhodopsin. You can rez a peptide live on IBM Almaden and there is even an SL Molecular Structure Group due to have its first meeting later this month. There is a fledgling database of structure availability/deployment hosted off the wiki at as well as a script that does a little of the parsing from pdb files. As a personal project I’m hoping to produce a toolkit that makes this kind of build more accessible to teachers and students. We had an informal meeting on ANGEL just before Christmas which I recorded on my blog, . It was just great seeing those structures rez! (SL: Graham Mills)

  3. Giulio Prisco Says:

    Great article as usual! Here are my observations:

    I think there is space for both QF and SL: Second Life is meant as a game-like social VR world with an added (still limited) set of groupware features, whereas Qwaq Forums is a virtual Intranet / Extranet for productivity-oriented groupware aimed at professional users. A company or organization may use QF as an internal workspace, training system and meeting space, and SL for public outreach to wider audiences in “fun” game-like settings.

    Yet it would be interesting to sort of merge the two sets of features at the platform level (one platform for both usage patterns). Perhaps OpenSim? Integrating the groupware features of QF in OpenSim is a challenge, but is certainly doable.

10 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Astronomy Pictures - Images of moon Says:

    [...] “Exploring Reality in Virtual Worlds” with Piet Hut By admin Science goes back to astronomy, studying the regularity of the heavens, and moderns science started with Galileo. Yet, though astrophysics is the oldest science, it is the youngest laboratory science. Until half a century ago it had no … UgoTrade – [...]

  2. The Daily Graze » Blog Archive » Collaborating in Virtual Worlds Says:

    [...] upon Professor Piet Hut’s paper titled Virtual Laboratories and Virtual Worlds by way of UgoTrade. Professor Hut documents his experiences using Qwaq as a meeting and collaboration space. Hut [...]

  3. Open Social How To » “Exploring Reality in Virtual Worlds” with Piet Hut Says:

    [...] Original post by UgoTrade [...]

  4. Exploring Reality in Virtual Worlds « PacificRim Exchange Says:

    [...] “Exploring Reality in Virtual Worlds” with Piet Hut [...]

  5. UgoTrade » 2008 » January » 28 Says:

    [...] New Forms of Collaboration The biggest problem in computational science, which is quickly becoming all of science, is to find ways to let scientists write software together. (Piet Hut) [...]

  6. UgoTrade » Blog Archive » NASA, Astrophysicists and Space Enthusiasts in Virtual Worlds Says:

    [...] I posted here about my visit to the awesome replica of the International Space Station in Second Life built by Illusion Factory. And how Piet Hut (see more about Piet’s latest Second Life adventures below!) brought his friend, astronaut Ed Lu, into Second Life to visit the International Space Station in Second Life. Ed Lu lived in the real one for a half a year in 2003! [...]

  7. Touchstone Moments « Play as Being Weblog Says:

    [...] SL interview with me Pema Pera: a few months ago already Pema Pera: let me find the URL Pema Pera: Hotaru Myoo: nice…thank you Pema Pema Pera: ancient, more than four months ago Pema Pera: one [...]

  8. Causes and Conditions « Play as Being Weblog Says:

    [...] Pera: She was he one who did an interview with me a few months ago, let me get the URL Pema Pera: Pema Pera: and guess what: during our interview I was in Japan and she in the US Pema Pera: and [...]

  9. UgoTrade » Blog Archive » Astrophysics in Virtual Worlds: Implementing N-Body Simulations in OpenSim Says:

    [...] worlds through the Meta Institute for Computational Astrophysics (MICA) for quite a while now (see my previous post). And, Piet and Eiko Ikegami have just published a fascinating paper about Japanese History and [...]

  10. Collaborating in Virtual Worlds « The Electric Sheep Company Says:

    [...] upon Professor Piet Hut’s paper titled Virtual Laboratories and Virtual Worlds by way of UgoTrade. Professor Hut documents his experiences using Qwaq as a meeting and collaboration space. Hut [...]

Leave a Reply